Does Standing Require Injury?

The 1974 Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act bars, among other things, kickbacks by title insurance companies. Under the law a plaintiff can sue without having to show actual injury. At least that was the argument made by the lawyer representing Denise Edwards, the homebuyer in this case who sued First American Financial Corp. SC111128_Lamken

But it was an uphill battle. Justice Scalia questioned, “I’m not even sure it’s proper to call it a kickback. It’s a commission.” And Justice Alito told Edwards’ attorney, Jeffrey Lamken, “We are looking for whether there is injury in fact.” SC111128_Panner

In his rebuttal Aaron M. Panner, the lawyer for First American, reaffirmed that “what is required is an injury-in-fact, a harm to the plaintiff who is seeking to obtain redress from the courts.

Mike Sacks brilliant analysis of the argument is here.




Art Lien

Courtartist is me, Art Lien. I've been sketching the courts since 1976, and for most of that time the U.S. Supreme Court has been my regular beat. I've been working almost exclusively for NBC News since 1980. Courtroom sketching is a form of visual journalism or reportage drawing that is slowly dying out. Where once upon a time news organization each had their own artist covering a story, today a "pool" artist often sketches for all. It is a demanding and stressful discipline where the drawing is often done directly and under tight deadline.

Tagged with: ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *